Review: Eat Pray Love

Posted by: Emily in General

Emily

If you enjoyed Sex and the City 2  for the friendship-centric, over-the-top fantasy romp that it was, then think of Eat Pray Love (opening today) as Sex’s more bookish, solitary, and endearing kid sister. This film adaptation of Elizabeth Gilbert’s best-selling post-divorce travel memoir, starring Julia Roberts as Gilbert, has equally eye-popping exotic locales (namely Italy, India, and Indonesia), sumptuous natural scenery, and decadent attention to detail. But instead of taking viewers along on a madcap safari of conspicuous American consumerism abroad, Eat Pray Love follows Gilbert on a quest for something much more elusive than a trip on a private Saudi jet—she’s looking for inner peace.

In the film’s opening scenes, we are introduced to a tightly wound, urbanite version of Gilbert—a woman in her 30s just coming to the realization that the life she’s so carefully crafted for herself has become intolerable. In response, she shakes things up, and the fallout is major. She loses her husband (Billy Crudup), her home, her money, and even her rebound relationship (James Franco), plus her friends think she’s nuts. But out of the rubble of what used to be her life emerges a delicious, exciting, escape plan. Gilbert will leave everything she knows behind and make three pilgrimages over the course of the next year. First, she’ll reconnect with pleasure by living in Rome, eating everything in sight, and learning Italian. Next, she’ll spend four months immersed in rigorous devotional practice at an Ashram in India to reacquaint herself with a sense of the divine. And finally, she will end her journey with an apprenticeship under an ancient Balinese medicine man (Hadi Subiyanto) who, when they met two years earlier, promised to teach her everything he knows in exchange for English lessons. It is through these three excursions that Gilbert hopes to rediscover a sense of self, purpose, and balance. But only time will tell if she can rise to the many opportunities and challenges each locale has in store for her.

As an audience member, if you’re the kind of person who would begrudge Gilbert this odyssey because you and most people you know could never afford the luxury of spending a year traveling to find yourself (and I’ve heard this complaint a lot), then it’s important to note that this a stumbling block the film does little to overcome. But if the idea of Gilbert’s escape and reinvention instead strikes you as an appealing daydream you wouldn’t mind losing yourself in for a few hours (two and a half hours to be exact—pee beforehand ladies!), then this gentle, meditative, well-told tale has a lot to offer. [Emily Rems]

Tagged in: Julia Roberts , General , Elizabeth Gilbert , Eat Pray Love   

The opinions expressed on the BUST blog are those of the authors themselves and do not necessarily reflect the position of BUST Magazine or its staff.



Trackback(0)
Comments (15)Add Comment
0
...
written by Juliette, August 13, 2010
Since I (as well as so many others) have read the book, I'm really curious to see if you thought there were any major discrepancies between the movie and the book. There usually are, so I'm prepared, but I'm curious all the same!
Emily
...
written by Emily, August 13, 2010
Hey Juliette! I also read the book, and what surprised me the most wasn't what the script chose to leave out, but rather what the screenwriters decided to add in. I won't spoil anything for you, but suffice it to say there are definitely a few moments that will leave you wondering where the heck they came from.
0
...
written by Juliette, August 14, 2010
Emily, thanks so much for responding! I'm so curious now -hopefully I'll find an English version showing near me! =P
williepiner
...
written by Wrinkle Cream, August 14, 2010
My favorite was actually Eat Pray Love. I was looking forward to The Lovely Bones, but it kind of disappointed me, especially the ending. It feels like it sort of … peters out, I guess.
0
...
written by Glamour Smiles, August 16, 2010
Eat Pray Love is feel-good without being sappy or cheesy, and it gets at some very "human" issues (as does Lovely Bones, but in a different way).
0
...
written by citizenjane2, August 19, 2010
Meh. I was a little more impressed with this review: http://www.salon.com/life/feat..._me_myself
0
...
written by Enzie, August 20, 2010
I don't think people are critical of this movie because they're jealous of your money. They're critical of it because people who write stories like this think that going to Indonesia is like going to Narnia. I'm surprised that someone from a feminist publication would be so unreflective about this.

But I guess that's to be expected from the same magazine who did a cover story on the manga craze, but couldn't be bothered to talk to a single Japanese person. Who did you talk to? Courtney Love. I mean, what the FUCK.
0
...
written by Lauren L., August 20, 2010
"But instead of taking viewers along on a madcap safari of conspicuous American consumerism abroad, Eat Pray Love follows Gilbert on a quest for something much more elusive than a trip on a private Saudi jet—she’s looking for inner peace."

I guess that's true, but has anyone else noticed the HUGE marketing campaign that's tied with this movie? Stores are shilling all kinds of crap "inspired" by the film, hoping that all of the well-off women who see it will be "inspired" to part ways with their cash for these trinkets.

I realize that most big budget movies have similar designs to sell us stuff, but to me it just feels especially shallow and wrong with a movie that is all about a journey of self discovery. I'm sure that Ms. Gilbert picked up a few things when she was on her pilgrimage, but that's SO not the point!

Women have a lot of spending (psuedo) power....and companies are waiting with bated breath to see how much moolah we'll part ways with after being "inspired" by this flick.

PS: Julia Roberts is supposed to be excellent, as always! smilies/smiley.gif
0
...
written by Emily S., August 20, 2010
For my part I hate the whole phenomena of 'Eat, Pray, Love,' and my hate is entirely unenlightened.

First, yes, it's horrible that a woman gets to take a very privileged sojourn to "find herself" in exotic locales, and then make money on the less privileged who purchase her book.

Secondly, (and this is the uncharming part) I'm just disgusted about how much money Ms. Gilbert is making, period. Let's call a spade a spade. When Paris Hilton writes books on how to be a heiress, we get a sneak peak into a shallow person's privileged life. I don't see Ms. Gilbert's work as any different. (I didn't read Ms. Hilton's book(s), but I read Ms. Gilbert's.) And I find myself being angry at Ms. Gilbert and not at Ms. Hilton because at least Ms. Hilton has *not* claimed that her books and journeys are for the purpose of self-renewal and inner enlightenment--they're to make cash and promote her lavish lifestyle. I do not see Ms. Gilbert's work as any different, and for her to dip into the pool of people who wish for and are curious about enlightenment to fatten her coffers just makes me so angry. Because, after all, she's just exploiting what I see so often--individuals who think that they can follow the middle path and attain enlightenment through outright purchase. It cheapens these pursuits, and makes the reader/viewer believe that self-awareness and a deep, meditative understanding of the world can be achieved through outright extravagance and indulgence, which, if we reflect, we all know it cannot. In fact, it has the potential to pull you further away.

If I would ask anything of Ms. Gilbert and this movie, it's to admit that these jet-fueled, globe-trotting romps are an expensive, mostly unattainable, and superficial way to realize an enlightened self. But, of course, that would never be admitted, because it would be sure to injure the ability of this movie and these books to make real money.

Also, for those who simply watch the movie for simple escapism and enjoyment, my rant is not intended for you. I understand the need to indulge and have fun in the entertaining things we watch and read. However, if someone reads this book and has the impulse to spend a year and large amount of money to experienced a heightened sense of self, then I speak caution, and please question Ms. Gilbert's means of attaining that goal.
0
...
written by Brigitte H., August 20, 2010
As my mother would say, "Bring that down to where I live."

Is it possible in our culture today to have a woman who is a wife and a mother, who works, who is not privileged enough to travel anywhere but the occasional coffee house on the rare day off...is it possible to have that woman become 'enlightened'? Without traveling to India? Without resenting her responsibility laden life? Without cheating on her husband, without leaving her life behind?

Maybe let's just work on this one- can it happen without leaving her real life behind? Or must we, glorify our escapist dreams by deeming them searching for enlightenment? It's a fantasy of escape, one that has little to do with true day to day spiritual searching.

I have a problem with the whole 'search for enlightenment' idea- how different is it to the zen practiced by the beats in the sixties? No great attachment to anything but the freedom to indulge in your appetites- a great Eastern spiritual excuse to act in a socially irresponsible way?
0
...
written by Christin, August 20, 2010
I saw this and loved it. The "stumbling block" of which you speak of was never a problem for me. I spent a year abroad my junior year of college and I can speak firthand, it is possible to travel and live very cheap abroad (especially in a place like India). Anyone could accomplish something like this with a little determination and a small savings account. Other than that, I thought the movie was spot on to how being abroad can change you as a person and open your life to new and exciting possibilities.
0
...
written by Annieb, August 20, 2010
gag me with a gelato spoon
0
...
written by Brigitte H., August 21, 2010
Dear Christin, who paid for your airfare? What job did you not have to leave to go abroad? Traveling during college, whiole wonderful for you, is not what this character did. There is a great difference between going abroad while unmarried, having no children, having no career, and having the permission of society to travel during that time in your life. Tell me about how cheap airfare to India, Italy and Indonesia is when you have to work minumum wage sixty ours a week to feed yourself, stay housed, and perhaps help care for others.

Not to knock your travel experiences. But how did you pay for all that travel? It's not in country that's the probelm dear, it's LEAVING THIS ONE.
0
...
written by P90X, March 05, 2011
I have a problem with the whole 'search for enlightenment' idea- how different is it to the zen practiced by the beats in the sixties? No great attachment to anything but the freedom to indulge in your appetites- a great Eastern spiritual excuse to act in a socially irresponsible way?
P90X
0
...
written by KellyP6, September 03, 2011
I thought this was such a great movie! It was definitely Julie Roberts at her finest. I don't spend a whole lot of time watching movies these days because I am always busy watching my kids but this was one that was worth making time for. If you haven't already seen it, think about a quiet movie night with a rental.

http://www.howtobecomeanrn.org

Can anyone recommend any other good Julia Roberts films?

Write comment

busy